When Questions Feel Like Criticism (And What to Do About It)


Friend...

Have you ever asked a simple question at work, only to have your manager or coworker react defensively—like you’ve just questioned their entire existence? Maybe you’ve been on the other side, feeling like every question is a subtle jab at your competence.

This dynamic is more common than we talk about, and it often stems from past workplace trauma. If someone has spent years under manipulative leadership, where questions were used as traps or disguised critiques, they might struggle to see curiosity as anything but a challenge. And if trust has never been part of their professional (or personal) experience, it makes sense that they’d brace for impact anytime someone asks, “Why do we do it this way?”

But here’s the thing: Questions are not critiques. They’re opportunities. Opportunities to clarify, to improve, to collaborate. When we shut down questions, we’re not just protecting our ego—we’re limiting what’s possible.

If You Struggle With Feeling Questioned

If questions immediately put you on the defensive, try this:

  • Pause before reacting. Ask yourself, “Is this a genuine question, or am I assuming an attack?”
  • Separate the question from past experiences. Your coworker isn’t your old toxic boss. Give them a fair shot.
  • Reframe it as curiosity. Assume positive intent. What if they just want to learn, not undermine you?

If You Have a Manager or Coworker Who Reacts Poorly to Questions

  • Validate before asking. Start with, “I really appreciate the work you’ve put into this. I have a question about…”
  • Stay neutral. Avoid “why” questions (which can feel accusatory) and try “What led to this decision?” instead.
  • Acknowledge their expertise. Sometimes, people need to feel seen before they feel safe answering.

Workplace culture improves when we stop mistaking curiosity for critique. If you’re navigating this dynamic at work, hit reply and tell me how you’ve handled it—I’d love to hear.

Talk soon,
P.S. I’m curious—have you experienced this at work? Do you feel like questions are welcomed in your workplace, or do they put people on edge? Reply and let me know, or take this quick poll to share your experience!

Click here to Suggest a Topic

🆘 Get Support with TDJ's Products

Freebies and More →

🔓 Unlock Your LinkedIn Potential

Get the workbook →

🎧 Binge the Podcast

Listen to all episodes now →

Support my work. Make a difference today! Leave a tip here!

Tramelle w/ TDJ Consulting

I’m a career planning enthusiast dedicated to helping you overcome obstacles and create strategies that lead you to roles where you’re valued, challenged, and paid what you’re worth. Join my email community!

Read more from Tramelle w/ TDJ Consulting

Friend... Recently, a friend told me they were looking for a job. When I asked what they wanted to do, they said, “I’ll do anything.” I immediately told them, That’s the worst thing you can say. It’s basically like saying, “Give me the bottom of the barrel.” So I pushed back, "No, really—what do you WANT to do?" That’s when they started opening up, telling me how they ran a digital store where they designed and sold clothing with their own artwork. They were a digital artist. An author. A...

Proactive vs. Reactive and how processing emotions before they process you can be powerful in your career!

Friend... Last time, we talked about how emotions don’t just disappear when we ignore them... they wait. And when they finally demand attention, it’s usually at the worst possible time. This doesn’t just apply to personal emotions, it happens in our careers too. Have you ever been fired (or left a job under tough circumstances) and told yourself, That’s in the past, I don’t need to think about it anymore? But then, months later, when you’re in an interview and asked why you left that job, all...

Processing  Emotions:  Don’t Let Them  Wait in Line

Friend... Sometimes, we face tough decisions, and our instinct is to push our feelings aside. We tell ourselves we’ll deal with them later—when we have more time, when things aren’t as stressful, when we feel ready. But here’s the thing: if you don’t process your emotions, they don’t just disappear. They wait. And then, at the most random moment, they come crashing in. I used to tell my clients that avoiding emotions is like making them wait in line. They don’t leave. They just stand there,...